Astor Street (St. Johns Riverfront)
On Astor Street on the St. Johns River waterfront in the historic Orange Park district, The Club Continental Suites (4.3, 171 reviews) is the town's single hot-tub-search hotel — a 4-star 1923 Mediterranean-revival estate with pool, tennis court, free breakfast, banquet rooms and conference facilities. Subratings 4.2-4.8 with a near-perfect 4.8 location. Themed guest rooms (English Room, Italian Room, and others) draw 'hidden gem' praise for their unique character — a 5-star guest wrote 'we arrived here for an overnight stay... stayed in the English room & our friends in the Italian room. Both were beautifully presented with lovely linen.' Candid 1-star flags on dated interiors and thin management. Best for Orange Park wedding guests, St. Johns River waterfront weekends and Jacksonville-suburb history-and-character seekers.