Eden House Key West

About The Hotel

Eden House Key West is a 4.6-rated (2,398 reviews) 100-year-old boutique property at 1015 Fleming Street with eclectic rooms, swim-up bar, bike rental and patio. Subratings run 4.2-4.7 with cleanliness 4.7, location 4.7 and service 4.7 as the strongest but rooms softer at 4.2. A 15-year returnee 5-star praised the ‘loft suite’ specifically — ‘read the room descriptions’ advice for the historic property with variable room sizes. CANDID FLAGS: multiple recent 3-stars flagged ‘ridiculously small rooms — barely move, no separate bathroom, barely get suitcases in the door’; a January-2026 1-star flagged an unresolved refund dispute as of May 2026 for ‘worst hotel customer service and unclean rooms.’ A 4-star from April 2026 gave a ‘few caveats’ review calling out the small first room. Boutique-property Old Town charm with the caveat of variable room sizes — book by room description.

What Guests Are Saying

“We loved Eden House! We have been traveling to KW 2-3x a year for about 15 years. We loved that you could choose the room(read the room descriptions), so we chose the loft suite and was perfect. Inside was spacious and had just the right things for a perfect stay. We enjoyed the balcony overlooking the pool. The room was clean and had no issues. Key West is old and many of the properties are very dated, but Eden has done a great job of keeping it up. The check-in staff was super friendly. It is situated in a perfect location to enjoy all the the Island offers. The pool was clean and well maintained along with the loungers/tables and tiki bar(free sunscreen in case you forgot to pack it). We were in town for the Song Writers Festival which can make it difficult to find rooms at a decent price and Eden was perfect!” — groovygirls25, 5 stars

“Visited week of NYE with my mom and we had an exceptional stay. The price was super approachable considering the holiday spike. Our room was clean, always refreshed and tidy. The location was also superb! Super convenient to explore neighboring areas, but tucked away enough from the traffic of Duval St., wharf & Mallory Square. The staff - front desk, Dredger’s Bar, housekeeping, etc. - were all very friendly & helpful, always recognizing us and answering any questions we had. We really enjoyed the pool area, too! We booked the prix fixe dinner at Azur for NYE and it was lovely. Despite our room being directly behind the pool bar, it didn’t feel loud ever. All-in-all, I would stay at Eden House again & recommend to others visiting Key West! Thank you for a memorable holiday vacation.” — Becky S., 5 stars

“A great experience at the Eden House. The manager Jocelyn the GM was delightful with all the 100 year history of the hotel. Made us feel at home !!! The Eden house has it all with the private and intimate pool and garden. Tiki bar was beautiful and close to pool for a relaxing drink 🍸” — Ronald H., 5 stars

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• 4.7 cleanliness, 4.7 location and 4.7 service subratings
• Swim-up bar and lovely pool area
• Historic 100-year-old property with character
• Loft Suite specifically recommended for space
• Bike rental and patio

Cons:

• Multiple recent 3-stars flagged ‘ridiculously small rooms’
• January 2026 1-star with unresolved refund dispute through May 2026
• Rooms subrating 4.2 — softest of the metrics
• Not every room type has space — book carefully

The Location

1015 Fleming Street, Key West, FL 33040 — In Old Town Key West, easy walk to Duval. You can find more details or book your stay on TripAdvisor.