Atlantis House

About The Hotel

Atlantis House is a 5.0-rated (537 reviews) two-unit adults-only Key West guesthouse at 1401 Atlantic Boulevard. Perfect 5.0 cleanliness and 5.0 service subratings, with 4.9 rooms, 4.9 sleep quality, 4.8 location and 4.8 value. Amenities include free parking, bicycles, boating arrangements, airport transportation and couples massage. Recent 5-stars are consistent: ‘everything we needed and Captain Steve was the best,’ ‘our Key West home away from home,’ and ‘the new owner Shari continues 5-star reputation.’ A 4-day 5-star in March called it ‘walking distance to the beach, great vibe’ and said ‘when we go back this is where we’ll stay.’ The highest-rated stay in Key West by subratings — a two-unit small guesthouse rather than a hotel, so book early. Not in-room whirlpool — the appeal is perfect-rating small-guesthouse hospitality.

What Guests Are Saying

“Every year we do an annual trek to Key West, we have stayed in a few places but nothing beats the Atlantis House. We are very excited with the new owner (Shari) who is dedicated to improving this wonderful tropical retreat. She has updated the rooms with with new decor, improved appliances, furniture, bedding and an ice maker on site (check out the website as many of the above pictures are before the renovation). What we really like is the focus on the guest. Shavon is the local Manager and does everything to make your stay first class…any questions or help he responds within quick timely manner. The location is great, steps away from the beach, bike are available to use and walking distant to many attractions and restaurants-Salute on the Beach is just a 5 minute walk with great dinner and drinks. On site parking is a bonus. The room is beyond comfortable and we love the mini kitchen and bar, the bathroom is almost as big as the main room. The outside deck is a wonderful place to kick back, a mini oasis with comfort seating where you can grill or eat outside. One of the best points is that there are only 2 suites and it creates a very secluded atmosphere. We have already booked November 2023 and can’t wait. Thank you Shari and Shavon for always making our trip special!” — ishkbibel, 5 stars

“We stayed at the Atlantis House for 4 days in March. This is a small 2 unit air b&b. We stayed in the garden suite. The unit had a small refrigerator, toaster, microwave and coffee maker. They supplied us with coffee to use in the coffee maker along with creamers, sugar, and also tea bags. The garden suite is the smaller of the 2 units but for our 4 day stay worked out. There is an shared outdoor area with tables and chairs. We were supplied with everything possible from soap, snacks and even sun block. The place was very clean. Our host Shavon was very friendly and answered all our questions and provided us with the entry codes to the room as well as the codes for the bike locks provided. The place is close to Higgs beach but a distance from Duval street. We used the bikes and rode to the nearest Duval street loop stop and used the free shuttle service to explore the attractions and dining.” — tdelpizzo1, 5 stars

“The host was absolutely treating us like family, in the good way - fresh key lime pie!! The accommodations themselves appear to be recently renovated, absolutely beautiful. Jacuzzi tub got some use, the open shower was nice and the deck/seating area was gorgeous day and night. It was a very short walk to the pier where we caught the sunrise, and only a 10 minute bike ride to the main attractions in Key West. Having access to the bikes from the host made our stay much more convenient. Got plenty of recommendations on local attractions, restaurants, et cetera from the host. If you’re looking for a place that is far enough that you feel separated from the noise of Duvall…but still want to be close to everything, it’s perfect. We’ll definitely be back! Thank you so much Shari and Shavon!” — Angelique D., 5 stars

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Perfect 5.0 cleanliness and 5.0 service subratings
• 5.0 overall rating across 537 reviews
• Adults-only two-unit guesthouse — private feel
• Free parking, bicycles, boating arrangements
• Owner Shari and Captain Steve consistently praised

Cons:

• Only two units — books far ahead
• A guesthouse rather than a hotel with pool
• On Atlantic side — 10-min drive to Duval
• A small guesthouse rather than in-room whirlpool property

The Location

1401 Atlantic Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040 — On the Atlantic side, walkable to Higgs Beach and 10-min drive to Duval. You can find more details or book your stay on TripAdvisor.