US-13 / Nelson Road (Eastern Shore Countryside)
The Nelson Road / US-13 rural Eastern Shore cluster in New Church is small but marquee, with the Garden and Sea Inn (4.8, 385 reviews) as the town's single hot-tub-search-relevant property. The Victorian B&B offers pool, boating, bicycle rental, free breakfast on the patio, meeting rooms and pet-friendly rooms — subratings run 4.4–4.9 across cleanliness (4.9), service (4.9), sleep quality (4.9) and rooms (4.8). Best for Chincoteague Pony Swim visitors, Eastern Shore birders and boutique-inn couples wanting a Victorian B&B alternative to Chincoteague Island lodging, 15 minutes from the wild ponies.