Smithfield Station Hotel

About The Hotel

Smithfield Station Hotel on South Church Street in Smithfield is a 4.5-rated Pagan River waterfront boutique with a pool, waterfront restaurant, fishing dock, boater services, conference facilities and rooms above the restaurant with water views. Subratings run 4.4–4.7 with cleanliness (4.7) and location (4.7) both strong. One 2024 review flags outdated safety features and one 2025 stay reports a $265 smoking-charge dispute — verify the specific room type at check-in. Best for Pagan River waterfront and historic-downtown couples and Chesapeake Bay boaters.

What Guests Are Saying

“We had a great time! All the facilities are in great shape and well maintained. Beds were quite comfortable and the room was nicely appointed. That shower was awesome. Staff was always helpful and friendly. Can’t beat where your place is. It’s fun and beautiful. It’s right in the midst of such a historic setting. We truly wish to return.” — Steven R., 5 stars

“Took my wife there for her Birthday! We had a wonderful time! We stayed above the restaurant and the room and scenery were great! the pool was awesome too! The staff was great and welcoming. The food was good and the bar staff each day were friendly. We will definitely be going back soon.” — Dan O., 5 stars

“We had a wonderful couple of days. I love the hotel and we had a small dinner in the bar which was perfect. Very good food. Morning breakfast was a pleasant surprise. I hadn’t expected it. Rooms were clean and staff super. I enjoy family run operations. We will return.” — David S., 5 stars

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• A 4.5 rating with 4.7 cleanliness and 4.7 location subratings.
• Pagan River waterfront location with rooms above the restaurant.
• Pool, waterfront restaurant, fishing dock and boater services on site.
• Walking distance to downtown Smithfield’s historic district.
• Manicure spa service on site along with conference facilities.

Cons:

• No in-room jacuzzi or shared hot tub advertised.
• One 2024 review flags outdated safety features (stairwell doors, no visible cameras).
• One 2025 stay reports $265 smoking-charge dispute despite non-smoking room use.
• One review notes damp room needing humidifier dumps twice daily — verify room condition at check-in.

The Location

On South Church Street on the Pagan River waterfront in Smithfield, Isle of Wight County. Historic downtown Smithfield’s Main Street is walking distance; Newport News/Williamsburg International Airport (PHF) is about 25 minutes east via the James River Bridge. You can find more details or book your stay on TripAdvisor.