Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference
"Island's largest waterfront-village resort with outdoor pool, free breakfast, steps to bars and ferry. Aging 3.4-rated property."
About The Hotel
The Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference Center is South Bass Island’s largest accommodation, a waterfront-village property that anchors the downtown on Loraine Avenue. Built for groups and seasonal island tourism, the resort offers an outdoor pool with a poolside bar, free breakfast, and direct access to the summer bar scene and ferry dock. Amenities include free parking, WiFi, and event facilities. This is a pool hotel, not an in-room-jacuzzi property, and it is an aging property with mixed reviews on rooms and management. Best for groups prioritizing location and convenience; couples seeking upscale or romantic retreats should consider mainland alternatives.
What Guests Are Saying
“Amazing Experience! We stayed in the loft at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center. The space was clean, comfortable, and perfect for our trip. We especially loved hanging out by the pool at the Blue Marlin Bar & Grille. The best vibes and a fun spot to spend the day. The location of this Resort is perfection. It is just a short walk to the lively downtown area. The employees are all so friendly and helpful, which made the stay even better. I highly recommend this resort if you’re heading to Put-in-Bay! The best place to stay on the Island!” — alexa W., 5 stars
“Huge shoutout to Bam Bam for taking pool security to levels I didn’t know were possible. I’ve never felt safer at the Blue Marlin Pool Bar. Not once did I worry about any suspicious pool-related activity under his watch. Friendly, professional, and always keeping a close eye on the water. If the pool ever decides to cause trouble, Bam Bam will be ready. Thanks to him and the whole security team for making safety their top priority! WE CANNOT WAIT TO GO BACK” — Brycetyn H., 5 stars
“True, fantastic experience. A great staff and all of them were very friendly. Awesome rooms and room service. Fun pool and hot tub area. The outside swim up bar had exceptional food. Met the owner and his son. Would definitely stay at this resort every time we go to Put-In-Bay.” — jamesgL3676CL, 5 stars
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Island’s largest hotel and most convenient central location on the downtown waterfront
- Outdoor pool with poolside bar and free breakfast included
- Steps from bars, restaurants, and ferry docks; walking distance to caves and attractions
- Good for groups with event facilities and conference space on site
- Affordable compared to mainland resort alternatives
Cons:
- Aging property (3.4 rating, 932 reviews) with mixed reviews on cleanliness and room condition—confirm details before arrival
- A pool hotel without in-room jacuzzis; no spa or luxury amenities
- Lively, noisy summer environment dominated by bar crowds; not suitable for quiet retreats
- Seasonal island ferry access; winter service is suspended
The Location
439 Loraine Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456. On South Bass Island’s waterfront village on Loraine Avenue, within walking distance of the downtown bars, restaurants, shops, Perry’s Cave/Family Fun Center, and the Miller Ferry and Jet Express docks. You can find more details or book your stay on TripAdvisor.
Put-in-Bay,
Put-in-Bay.
Guest reviews
What guests are saying about Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference.
"Awesome spot. Me and my 4 friends stayed in a luxury suite and it fit us just fine. Short walk to the pool bar and less then 10 minute walks to most everything else on the island. So it's a great location. The 24 hour desk comes in handy. We had a mix up with how many days we needed to stay. And they fixed it so fast. Katlyn and Steve should get a bonus for how well they're treating their customers. If you're coming to Put-in-Bay and you want a good location for a good price. The resort and conference center is a great spot."
— Josiah Fideler
View on Google"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Exceptional Service from Maddy and Jenny! I had the pleasure of staying at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center recently, and I can't say enough great things about the staff—especially Maddy and Jenny. From the moment we arrived, both of them went above and beyond to ensure our stay was smooth, comfortable, and enjoyable. Maddy was incredibly welcoming, professional, and always ready with a smile. She handled check-in quickly and efficiently, and throughout our stay, she was more than happy to answer questions, offer recommendations, and help us navigate the island. Jenny brought a warmth and kindness that made the whole experience feel more personal. Her attention to detail and genuine care for guests really stood out. Whether it was assisting with requests or simply checking in to make sure we had everything we needed, she made us feel like valued guests. Together, Maddy and Jenny are a fantastic team—professional, friendly, and truly committed to great hospitality. They’re a big reason why I’ll be recommending this resort to friends and planning a return visit soon! Thank you both for making our stay so memorable"
— Eric Riehle
View on Google"Our visit to Put-In-Bay Resort exceeded expectations! The rooms and common areas were extremely clean and well-kept, which immediately made us feel comfortable and relaxed. The staff was amazing — so friendly, welcoming, and always ready to help. Whether it was answering questions, offering local tips, or helping with small requests, they were consistently kind and professional. What really impressed us was how accommodating they were throughout our stay. They made sure everything ran smoothly and that we had everything we needed to enjoy our trip. This resort strikes the perfect balance between fun and relaxation. We’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend it to anyone planning a trip to Put-In-Bay!"
— Liz Perry
View on GooglePowered by Google