The Old Manse Inn

About The Hotel

The Old Manse Inn occupies a beautifully restored sea-captain’s house on Main Street in Brewster, with antique-filled rooms, gourmet breakfasts that change daily, and an atmosphere of genuine warmth and hospitality. It holds a 4.9 across 1,000 reviews, with guests praising hosts Brain and Charlie, the charming Lewis Bay Light Suite, complimentary afternoon snacks, and the sense of being welcomed as a guest in a gracious home rather than as a room number. The inn provides beach gear, a full breakfast each morning with a different menu and special story, and a relaxed, elegant setting perfect for couples seeking a refined but approachable Cape Cod escape. At $432–$444 per night, it sits at the higher end of Brewster rates but delivers an exceptional experience.

What Guests Are Saying

“We had a wonderful time at Old Manns Inn. The house has a lot of charm, especially the Lewis Bay Light Suite. The hosts, Brain and Charlie, and all the staff were very friendly and made us feel right at home. The welcome with name tags and national flags was very individual and personal. The complimentary afternoon snack (cheese, wine, nuts) from Wednesday to Sunday, accompanied by pleasant conversations with other guests, was particularly appealing. Every morning, there is a different breakfast menu with a special story, which we enjoyed on the beautiful terrace or in the dining room. Brewster is ideally located on Cape Cod for excursions in every direction.” — Uwe K., 5 stars

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• 4.9 across 1,000 reviews — exceptional and beloved
• A restored sea-captain’s house full of warmth and character
• Gourmet breakfasts, complimentary beach gear, and afternoon snacks included
• Hosts known for genuine hospitality and personal attention
• A central 6A location near the bay, the flats, and the antique shops

Cons:

• Among the higher Brewster rates ($432–$444 per night)
• A romantic historic B&B rather than a full-service resort
• No shared pool or hot tub is listed — confirm an in-room whirlpool at booking
• Books up far ahead for summer and fall weekends

The Location

On Main Street (Route 6A) in Brewster’s historic district, near the flats, the beaches, and the antique shops. You can find more details or book your stay on TripAdvisor.